Internal controls
SOX controls for travel and expense: a practical checklist for T&E
Travel and expense is rarely material to the financial statements, yet it is where auditors test the control environment, and where executive expenses become disclosure issues. Here are the controls that hold up in a SOX audit.
Quick answer
- Written policy approved by management, with limits by expense type.
- Segregation of duties: nobody approves their own expenses; executive expenses are approved one level up (CFO, audit committee chair).
- Receipt verification against the claimed line, and duplicate detection across employees.
- Corporate card reconciliation and timely submission.
- Evidence: every check, exception and approval kept with an audit trail.
Why T&E matters in a SOX audit
Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires management to assess internal control over financial reporting (ICFR), and the external auditor to attest to it for larger filers. T&E amounts are usually small compared to revenue, but auditors look at them for three reasons:
- Control environment: how management's own expenses are approved says a lot about tone at the top.
- Executive perquisites: personal benefits paid through expense reports may have to be disclosed in the proxy statement. The SEC has brought enforcement actions over undisclosed perks.
- Fraud risk: expense reimbursement schemes are one of the most frequent forms of occupational fraud reported by the ACFE.
The T&E control checklist
| Control | Type | What the auditor will ask |
|---|---|---|
| T&E policy approved and communicated | Entity-level | Policy version, approval date, employee acknowledgment |
| No self-approval; approval routed by hierarchy | Preventive | Workflow configuration, list of approval overrides |
| Executive expenses approved above the executive | Preventive | Approver for C-level reports, audit committee review |
| Receipt required above threshold, matched to the line | Preventive | Threshold settings, exceptions and how they were cleared |
| Duplicate expense detection | Detective | Rule logic, period covered, cross-employee coverage |
| Corporate card reconciliation, unsubmitted transactions | Detective | Aging of unreconciled transactions |
| Post-payment audit | Detective | Population, sample or full coverage, results, follow-up |
| Access to the expense system | IT general control | Admin users, configuration change log |
Sample testing vs 100% coverage
Traditional post-payment audits review a random sample of reports, often a few percent. That gives the auditor a statistic, not assurance on the individual reports that were not drawn. Automated checks on every line, with exceptions routed to a reviewer, change the conversation: the control operates on the full population, and the evidence is the exception log itself.
When a sample is still needed (for an internal audit mission, for example), define the population first: expense type, country, amount, cost center, employee. Smart Extract for SAP Concur does exactly this, with the receipt on screen and a verdict per line.
Evidence that survives the audit
- The rule that ran, with its parameters and version.
- The list of exceptions it produced for the period.
- Who reviewed each exception, when, and the outcome (approved, rejected, recovered).
- Changes to the rules over the period, and who approved them.
EVA keeps this trail for every expense line checked. Related: IRS receipt requirements, continuous expense auditing, expense audit checklist, how to compare expense audit software.
Sources
- Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, Section 404
- PCAOB Auditing Standard AS 2201 — An Audit of Internal Control Over Financial Reporting
- SEC Regulation S-K, Item 402 — Executive compensation and perquisites disclosure
- ACFE — Occupational Fraud: A Report to the Nations
This guide is general information and does not replace the advice of your auditors.
Frequently asked questions
Is travel and expense in scope for SOX?
T&E is rarely material, but it is part of internal control over financial reporting and of the control environment that auditors assess, especially for executive expenses and perquisites.
Who should approve executive expense reports?
Someone above the executive: typically the CFO for other executives, and the audit committee chair or board for the CEO. Self-approval should be technically impossible in the expense tool.
Is sampling enough for a T&E control?
Sampling gives a statistical view but no assurance on reports that were not drawn. Automated checks on every line, with exceptions reviewed and logged, give full coverage and stronger evidence.
What evidence do auditors expect for T&E controls?
The rule that ran and its version, the exceptions it produced for the period, who reviewed each exception and the outcome, and any change to the rules with its approval.
